Bill Cosby Accuser Seeks His Return to Prison, Claims He Has Not Paid $59 Million Judgment

Donna Motsinger is asking a judge to hold Bill Cosby in contempt of court, claiming the comedian has failed to pay a $59.25 million civil judgment or provide information about his finances.

Bill Cosby is facing another legal challenge after a woman who won a multimillion dollar sexual assault judgment against him asked a judge to consider sending him back to jail.

Donna Motsinger, who accused Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting her in 1972, claims he has not paid any part of the $59.25 million judgment awarded to her earlier this year.

According to court documents reported by TMZ, Motsinger is also accusing Cosby of failing to comply with court orders requiring him to disclose information about his bank accounts, income and other assets.

She is now asking the court to hold him in contempt and issue an arrest warrant if he fails to appear before the judge.

Cosby Has Not Paid the Judgment, Accuser Claims

In March 2026, a California civil jury found Cosby liable for drugging and sexually assaulting Motsinger.

The jury awarded her $19.25 million in compensatory damages and an additional $40 million in punitive damages, bringing the total to $59.25 million.

Motsinger’s legal team says Cosby has not paid any portion of the award.

Her lawyers also claim he has failed to provide financial information despite being ordered to do so. A judge reportedly gave Cosby 10 days to turn over the requested records and pay $1,560 in sanctions following an October 9 order.

Motsinger claims he did not meet the deadline.

She Wants the Judge to Consider Jail Time

Motsinger is asking the court to take further action over what she describes as Cosby’s failure to follow court orders.

Her filing seeks an arrest warrant if he does not appear in court. She is also asking for fines of up to $1,000 and five days in jail for each alleged violation.

Additionally, she wants $3,284 in legal fees and costs.

Motsinger has also asked that Cosby remain in jail if he is found in contempt and continues refusing to comply with the court’s orders.

The requests are part of a civil judgment enforcement process. They do not mean that a judge has already ordered Cosby back to prison.

The Case Dates Back to 1972

Motsinger said she was working as a waitress at a restaurant in Sausalito, California, when she encountered Cosby in 1972.

In her lawsuit, she alleged that Cosby gave her wine and a pill that left her incapacitated before sexually assaulting her.

Cosby’s lawyers disputed her claims during the trial, arguing that the allegations relied on speculation. Cosby has maintained that any sexual contact he had with women was consensual.

The jury nevertheless found him liable in the civil case and awarded Motsinger damages.

Cosby Has Tried to Challenge the Verdict

Following the jury’s decision, Cosby sought to have the verdict overturned and requested a new trial.

In May 2026, a judge rejected his request.

His legal team has appealed the ruling, and that appeal remains pending.

Cosby’s attorney has argued that he was denied a fair trial, while Motsinger has described the jury’s decision as a major step toward accountability after decades of waiting.

A New Court Battle Is Ahead

The latest request could lead to another court appearance for Cosby as Motsinger continues trying to collect the judgment.

A hearing on her contempt request is scheduled for January 2027.

The judge will have to consider whether Cosby failed to comply with the court’s orders and what steps, if any, should follow.

For Motsinger, the dispute is about more than the size of the judgment. She is seeking to ensure that the court’s decision is enforced.

For Cosby, the case remains part of an ongoing legal battle as he challenges the civil verdict and faces questions about his finances.

Bill Cosby Accuser Seeks His Return to Prison, Claims He Has Not Paid $59 Million Judgment

Donna Motsinger is asking a judge to hold Bill Cosby in contempt of court, claiming the comedian has failed to pay a $59.25 million civil judgment or provide information about his finances.

Bill Cosby is facing another legal challenge after a woman who won a multimillion dollar sexual assault judgment against him asked a judge to consider sending him back to jail.

Donna Motsinger, who accused Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting her in 1972, claims he has not paid any part of the $59.25 million judgment awarded to her earlier this year.

According to court documents reported by TMZ, Motsinger is also accusing Cosby of failing to comply with court orders requiring him to disclose information about his bank accounts, income and other assets.

She is now asking the court to hold him in contempt and issue an arrest warrant if he fails to appear before the judge.

Cosby Has Not Paid the Judgment, Accuser Claims

In March 2026, a California civil jury found Cosby liable for drugging and sexually assaulting Motsinger.

The jury awarded her $19.25 million in compensatory damages and an additional $40 million in punitive damages, bringing the total to $59.25 million.

Motsinger’s legal team says Cosby has not paid any portion of the award.

Her lawyers also claim he has failed to provide financial information despite being ordered to do so. A judge reportedly gave Cosby 10 days to turn over the requested records and pay $1,560 in sanctions following an October 9 order.

Motsinger claims he did not meet the deadline.

She Wants the Judge to Consider Jail Time

Motsinger is asking the court to take further action over what she describes as Cosby’s failure to follow court orders.

Her filing seeks an arrest warrant if he does not appear in court. She is also asking for fines of up to $1,000 and five days in jail for each alleged violation.

Additionally, she wants $3,284 in legal fees and costs.

Motsinger has also asked that Cosby remain in jail if he is found in contempt and continues refusing to comply with the court’s orders.

The requests are part of a civil judgment enforcement process. They do not mean that a judge has already ordered Cosby back to prison.

The Case Dates Back to 1972

Motsinger said she was working as a waitress at a restaurant in Sausalito, California, when she encountered Cosby in 1972.

In her lawsuit, she alleged that Cosby gave her wine and a pill that left her incapacitated before sexually assaulting her.

Cosby’s lawyers disputed her claims during the trial, arguing that the allegations relied on speculation. Cosby has maintained that any sexual contact he had with women was consensual.

The jury nevertheless found him liable in the civil case and awarded Motsinger damages.

Cosby Has Tried to Challenge the Verdict

Following the jury’s decision, Cosby sought to have the verdict overturned and requested a new trial.

In May 2026, a judge rejected his request.

His legal team has appealed the ruling, and that appeal remains pending.

Cosby’s attorney has argued that he was denied a fair trial, while Motsinger has described the jury’s decision as a major step toward accountability after decades of waiting.

A New Court Battle Is Ahead

The latest request could lead to another court appearance for Cosby as Motsinger continues trying to collect the judgment.

A hearing on her contempt request is scheduled for January 2027.

The judge will have to consider whether Cosby failed to comply with the court’s orders and what steps, if any, should follow.

For Motsinger, the dispute is about more than the size of the judgment. She is seeking to ensure that the court’s decision is enforced.

For Cosby, the case remains part of an ongoing legal battle as he challenges the civil verdict and faces questions about his finances.

SIGN UP FOR
OUR NEWSLETTER

By subscribing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

MORE FOR YOU

Login

Don't have an account?